Ccase examine "Lugger versus Butchers"

 Ccase study «Lugger as opposed to Butchers» Analysis Paper

Case Study you - Dick Spencer

Clinton E Harris

Texas A& M College or university – Business

February 1, 2014


Dick Bradzino has resided the typical American businessman's success story. A college graduate student is chosen into an entry level sales position and establishes him self early on as a highly fruitful employee. Because the years progress, Dick's success has advanced him in the corporate structure to older leadership. The advancements have come at the price of his first relationship and the loss of his standing as a regular guy to that of a supervisor who is constantly looking over his subordinate's shoulder. In Dick's most recent promotion to Flower Manager for Modro, this individual inherited a division that heavily invested in the future simply by modernizing the plant and equipment. As a result of heavy capital investments the plant is operating at a loss, which was planned, Dick began to stress cost savings as a way to offset the losses. The strategy Dick uses to put into practice cost saving initiatives, along with his previously mentioned reputation as a meddler, were hampering the changes having been trying invoke. Issues Research

In studying this case, you will discover three related issues that point out Dick's ineffectiveness to create modify. First, Dick's choices in management style are not suitable for the positioning he retains. Micromanaging every aspect of the plant's operations is not only ineffective, nevertheless infers feeling to his subordinates. Becoming a leader is more than showing people how to proceed at every decision point. Subsequently, company morale is being afflicted with the preconceived ideas of Dick coming from his previous posts, in addition to the employee's fear of organizational alter. Lastly, strains from home your life and pressures of delivering results at your workplace have diminished Dick as being a competent supervisor. We is going to take a look at each of these issues, subsequently. Micromanagement

The shortcoming to delegate responsibility to subordinates stands out as the fundamental distance that exists in Dick Spencer as being a plant director. Many of the instances mentioned in case study really are a product of Dick's micromanagement. " Micromanagement is a style of management that is characterized by a great excessive requirement of control and extreme awareness of even seemingly trivial details” (Hernandez, 2012). The best example from this case may be the method of removal of scrap aluminum. The business enterprise as usual way of disposing of discarded in the reduce shop was indeed a cost driver and probably needed to be redesigned. Nevertheless due to Spencer's forceful setup, employees resorted to even more inefficient methods of cutting down discarded.

Micromanagement often not only obstructs functionality of a flower at the fine detail level, as i have said in the case of discarded disposal. A micromanager at a leadership position could be a detriment to a organization by neglecting the high level obligations and duties that are incumbent on their post by attending to the smallest information on operations. (White, 2010). Mainly because Spencer was so associated with minute particulars like " Hammers and Tongs”, this individual forgot that will put his shoes or boots back about before a gathering with general public officials.

White as well points out that a top weighty organizational pecking order can lead to micromanaging. This can happen from two scenarios, for the organization has too many levels, energetic managers have too little decisions to generate and feel compelled to shell out their free time micromanaging their particular subordinates. Second of all, a good manager may be micromanaged by their superior and think forced to the actual same their employees (White, 2010). The written text does not provide specific depth to either the organizational structure and also the behavior of Spencer's employer as a possible cause of his habit. It is really worth noting, yet , that during Dick's initial year because the plant director he had to generate numerous outings back to the house office, which may infer he was being continuously called for the carpet and can have been an adding factor.


Bibliography: Decker, K., Dupler, D., Protects, M. Q., Smith, C. E., & Thomas, Meters. (1998). Improving Quality simply by Improving Worker Morale. National Productivity Review National Output Review, Vol. 17(4), 65-68.

Evans, A. M., Carney, J. T., & Wilkinson, M. (2013). Work-Life balance for Men: Guidance Implications. Log of Counseling and Expansion, Vol. 91(1), 436-441.

Hawksley, B. (2007). Work Related Stress: Work/Life Balance. Uk Journal of Community Nursing, Vol. 12 (1), 34-36.

Hernandez, T. S. (2012). Am I Directing or Micromanaging? Physician Professional, Vol. 38(5), pp. 70-72.

Iqbal, M. Z., & Fatima, A. (2013). Interpersonal Conflict Controlling Styles: A. Pakistan Record of Internal Research, Pakistan Journal of Psychological Exploration, Vol. 28(1), 125-152.

Jassawalla, A., Truglia, C., & Garvey, Jennifer. (2004). Cross-cultural Conflict and Expatriate Manager Adjustment: An Exploratory Analyze. Management Decision, Vol. 42(7/8), 837.

Shelter, J., & Yeo, R. K. (2011). Quality of life and career advancement: perceptions of part-time MBA students. Staff Relations, Vol. 33(3), 201-220.

Schmidt, M. (2013). In your Service: Stalwart leadership Traditions Builds Efficeint and Results-focused Teams. Quality Progress, Vol. 46 (11), 38-43.

Sirman, R. (2008). Collaborative Command - A Solution to Sophisticated Problems. Employment Relations Today, Vol. 35(2), 31-42.

White, R. S. (2010). The Micromanagement Disease: Symptom, Diagnosis, and Cure. Public Workers Management, Volume. 39(1), 71-76.