consmption vs expenditure

 consmption as opposed to expenditure Article

Usage vs . Costs

Mark Aguiar

Federal Hold Bank of Boston

Erik Hurst

University of Chicago, il



We would like to thank Daron Acemoglu, Fernando Alvarez, Susanto Basu, Marianne

Bertrand, Mark Bils, Ricardo Caballero, Dorrie Davis, Lars Hansen, Jonathon Heathcote, Eileen Hurd, Anil Kayshap, Sue Levy, Ould - Lusardi, Frank Mayer, Amil Petrin, Karl Scholz, Deceive Shimer, Jon Skinner, Mel Stephens, Alwyn Young, Dorrie Zeldes, and two confidential referees, along with seminar participants on the Boston Fed, Brown, Chicago, Columbia, Fed Board of Governors, The state of michigan, MIT, NBER EFG, New York Fed, NYU, RAND, Williams, and Wisconsin, for their helpful comments. We could extremely happy of Rubbish bin Li for her exceptional research assistance. Both equally Aguiar and Hurst wish to acknowledge the financial support of the University or college of Chicago's Graduate School of Business. The views expressed in this paper are the authors' very own and do not automatically reflect those of the Federal government Reserve Bank of Boston or the National Reserve System.


Earlier authors include documented a dramatic fall in foodstuff expenditures at the time of retirement. We all show that the is matched by an equally dramatic within time put in shopping for and preparing meals. Using a story data collection that collects detailed foodstuff diaries for a large crosssection of U. S. people, we show that nor the quality nor the quantity of diet plan deteriorates with retirement position. We as well show that unemployed homes experience a decline in food spending and food consumption commensurate while using impact of job shift on everlasting income. These types of results focus on how direct measures of consumption distinguish between anticipated and unanticipated shock absorbers to cash flow while steps of costs obscure the distinction.

one particular



Standard tests of the long term income speculation (PIH) applying data about nondurables

typically equate ingestion with costs. 1

Nevertheless , as observed by Becker (1965),

intake is the output of " home production” which uses as advices both market expenditures and time. a couple of To the extent possible, individuals will substitute away from market expenditures because the comparable price of your energy falls. From this sense, could be opportunity expense of time has a direct bearing on the total cost of consumption, producing market costs a poor proxy server for actual consumption.

From this paper, all of us directly look at the link among food expenditures, time spent on food development, and genuine food consumption. To get this done, we make use of a novel dataset -- the Ongoing Survey of Food Intake of people (CSFII) – which paths the dollar value, the quantity, and the top quality of food consumed inside U. H. households. We discover that real estate agents, in response to forecastable profits changes, clean consumption, although not always expenditures, as predicted by standard PIH model increased with house production. We use this data to review two main stylized specifics in the household consumption materials: household non-durable consumption drops significantly during both retirement living and lack of employment. 3

Nearly all researchers documenting these special facts work with food

expenditures as their way of measuring nondurable usage. Some authors have construed the decline in spending at the start retirement as being evidence that some households do not program sufficiently pertaining to retirement (Bernheim et. al. (2001)), while others conclude that there is 1

This kind of literature is usually vast. Find surveys simply by Browning and Lusardi (1996) and Attanasio (1999). We use the conditions Permanent Income Hypothesis, Cycle Model, and " intake smoothing” to refer to the school of models in which agents seek a consistent marginal utility of consumption (up to a adjustment to get differences between time choice and the curiosity rate). 2

See as well Ghez and Becker (1975). Becker's understanding was revived and extended by, and the like, Benhabib, Rogerson,...

References: Aguiar, Mark and Erik Hurst (2004). " Consumption versus Expenditure", NBER Working Newspaper


Aguiar, Mark and Erik Hurst (2005), " Lifecycle Rates and Production” University of Chicago

operating paper.

Attanasio, Orazio G. (1999), " Consumption”, in John Taylor and Michael Woodford, impotence.

Banks, Wayne, Richard Blundell, and Sarah Tanner (1998), " Is There a Retirement-Savings

Dilemna? ", American Economic Review, Vol

Baxter, Marianne and Urban J. Jermann (1999), " Home Production plus the Excess

Level of sensitivity of Usage to Current Income”, American Economic Review, Vol

Becker, Gary (1965), " A Theory with the Allocation of Time”, Economical Journal 75 (299), pp.

Benhabib, Jess, Richard Rogerson, and Randall Wright (1991), " Home work in Macroeconomics:

Household Creation and Get worse Fluctuations”, Diary of Political Economy, Vol

99 (6), pp. 1166-1187.

Bernheim, W. Douglas, Jonathan Skinner, and Steven Weinberg (2001), " What Accounts for the

Variance in Pension Wealth amongst U. T

Bhattacharya, Jayanta, Janet Currie, and Steven Haider (2001). " Just how Should We all Measure

Craving for food? " Functioning Paper.

Bhattacharya, Jayanta, Jeremy Currie, and Steven Haider (2003). " Evaluating the Impact of School

Nutrition Programs, " USDA Final Report.

Blaylock, James Ur. (1989), " An Economic Model of Grocery Shopping Frequency", Applied

Economics, 21(6), pp 843-52.

Pistolet, Martin and Annamaria Lusardi (1996), " Household Financial savings: Micro Hypotheses and

Mini Facts”, Journal of Economic Literature, Vol

Cronovich, Ron, Rennae Daneshvary, and 3rd there’s r. Keith Bedenklich (1997), " The Determinants of Promotion

Usage, " Applied Economics, 29, pp

Ghez, Gilbert and Gary Becker (1975). The Allocation of Time and Goods within the Life Pattern,

Columbia University Press, New york city.

Greenwood, Jeremy and Zvi Hercovitz (1991), " The Allocation of Capital and Time within the

Business Routine, ” Log of Political Economy, Vol 99 (6), 1188-1214.

Haider, Steven and Mel Stephens (2003), " Can Unpredicted Retirement Expectations Explain the

Retirement Intake Puzzle? Facts from Subjective Retirement Expectations"

Huff-Stevens, Ann (1997), " Persistent Effects of Job Displacement: The Importance of Multiple

Work Losses”, Log of Labor Economics 15, 1, 165-88.

Hurd, Michael and Susann Rohwedder (2003), " The Retirement-Consumption Challenge:

Anticipated and Actual Declines in Spending at Retirement”, NBER Functioning Paper

Hurst, Erik (2003), " Grasshoppers, Ants, and Pre-Retirement Prosperity: A Test out of the Permanent

Income, ” NBER Functioning Paper 10098.

Juster, F. Thomas and Frank Stafford (1985), male impotence. Time, Products, and Health, University of

Michigan Press, 1985.

McGrattan, Ellen, Richard Rogerson, and Randall Wright (1997), " An Equilibrium Model of the

Business Pattern with Household Production and financial Policy”, Foreign Economic

twenty nine

Miniaci, Raffaele, Guglielmo Weber, and Chiara Monfardini (2002), " Do they offer a Retirement

Rios-Rull, Jose-Victor (1993), " Working in the Market, Work from home, and the Acquisition of

Skills: A General-Equilibrium Approach”, American Economical Review, Vol 83 (4), pp.

Rupert, Peter, Rich Rogerson, and Randall Wright (1995), " Estimating Alternative

Elasticities in Household Creation Models”, Monetary Theory, Vol 6, pp

Rupert, Philip, Richard Rogerson, and Randall Wright (2000), " Research in Labor Economics:

Household Production and Intertemporal Substitution”, Journal of Monetary Economics,

Stephens, Mel (2001), " The Long-Run Consumption Effects of Earnings Shocks”, Review of

Economics and Stats, Vol. 83 (1), pp. 28-36

Subramanian, Shankar and Angus Deaton (1996), " The Demand for Food and Calories", Journal

of Politics Economy, 104 (1), pp