Debating Muslim Political Representation
Discussing Muslim politics representation
THE political portrayal of American indian Muslims, probably the most contested politics questions in postcolonial India, has become very relevant in recent years primarily because of two important, yet distinct, reasons. The publication in the Sachar Panel report (The report from the Prime Minister's High Level Committee on Social, Economic and academic Status of Muslims in India вЂ“ PMHLC 2006) is the first reason behind the apparent resurrection of this issue. Although, the Sachar Committee was not asked to collect data/information on the вЂpolitical backwardness' of Indian Muslims, the main getting of the report and its various recommendations establish a clear website link between numerous forms of Muslim backwardness as well as the discourse of political representation. In analyzing the question of political personal strength of Muslims the committee underlines the down sides with the present delimitation of parliamentary and assembly constituencies as a result of which usually Muslims don’t have adequate politics representation in legislative systems. The post-Babri Masjid Muslim political task in India also performs a crucial role in re-conceptualising the idea of Muslim political portrayal. This new sort of Muslim national politics goes beyond the conventional Muslim personal concerns вЂ“ protection of Urdu, minority character in the Aligarh Muslim University, safety of Muslim Personal Legislation, and the safeguard of wakf вЂ“ by simply challenging the notion of a one homogeneous Of india Muslim community. The demand pertaining to caste-based booking for Muslim Dalits and OBCs plus the formation in the Muslim Women's Personal Law Board happen to be two exposing examples of the brand new radical Muslim politics. 1В Such claims apparently suggest that the idea of вЂMuslim representation' should be examined seriously, particularly in the perspective of marginalized Muslim groups. These recent innovations have improved the nature of debate on Muslim political representation. Merely establishing the number of Muslim MPs and MLAs can no longer solve this vexed question in the country/or concerned point out. In contrast, major is for the sociological difficulties of Muslim communities and their political assertions in relation to the responsiveness of political organizations. Thus, to be able to map out the various trends in the debate about Muslim representation in modern India, one needs a systematic examination of various positions, perspectives, issues and worries. This conventional paper discusses three theses in Muslim manifestation: (a) the legal-constitutional thesis; (b) the social-equality thesis; and (c) the secular-participation thesis, together illustrating the wider national politics of Muslim representation in contemporary India. 2 В
Let us start our conversation with theВ legal-constitutional thesisВ on Muslim representation which usually recognizes the Indian Muslim community as an identifiable religious community and envisages its suitable representation in legislative bodies so as to guarantee the implementation of the constitutional provisions linked to minority rights. This point of view derives their moral power from the Metabolic rate and emphasises the fact that, in principle, the success of Indian democracy will depend on an adequate and proper manifestation of hispanics in the decision-making process. The writings of Syed Shahabuddin and Iqbal A. Ansari are relevant in this regard. 3 This thesis is based on subsequent three broad assumptions:
1 ) There are some group identifiable passions of a pan-Indian Muslim community. 2 . Adequate (proportional) manifestation of Muslims is an important means to safeguard these collective interests in the existing legal-constitutional framework. three or more. Muslim political representation can be inextricably linked to legislative physiques. Therefore , we must think of a legally justifiable and constitutionally permissible alternate institutional design and style by which an adequate number of Muslim legislators (MPs, MLAs and...
References: Hilal Ahmed, Governmental policies of Typical monuments and Memory in Postcolonial North India: A Study of Muslim Political Discourse on Jama Masjid and Babri Masjid. Unpublished dissertation. University of London, 2007.
Rajeev Bhargava, Precisely what is Secularism For? In Rajeev Bhargava (ed. ), В Secularism and its Critics, Oxford University or college Press, Delhi, 1998.
Stacey Burlet, Gender Relations, вЂHindu Nationalism' and the NGO Answers in India. In Sweetman Caroline (ed. ), В Gender, Religion and Spirituality, Oxford, Oxfam, 1999.
Prime Minister's High Level Panel, Social, Economical and Educational Status of the Muslim Community of India, Federal government of India, 2006.
Francis Robinson, David Origin, Electronic. William and Subroto Roy (eds. ), В Foundation of Pakistan's Politics Economy: To an Agenda intended for the nineties, Sage, Fresh Delhi, 1992.
Anil Sadgopal and Shayam Bahadur Namr, В Sangharsh Aur Nirman: Shahid Shankar Guha Niyogi aur Unka Naye Bharat Ka SapnaВ (Hindi), Rajkamal, Delhi, 93.
Moin Shakir, В Islam in Indian National politics, Ajanta Distribution, Delhi, 1983.
Yoginder Sikand, В Indian Muslims Since 1947: Islamic Points of views on Inter-Faith Relations, Routledge Curzon, Greater london and New York, 2004.
Khan 2004, Int.: Interview with Khan Abdul Wadud Khan, Ex-Member of Legislative Council, Uttar Pradesh, 1984-1990, Ex-Wakf officer, Delhi Wakf Plank, Delhi, 27 January 2005.